What to Choose: Standing Desk vs. Sit-Stand Converter?
Every month we have thousands of readers researching this very question on our websites, so we thought it time to dedicate an article to the discussion. When is it best to move aside your old desk, replacing it wholesale with a new sit-stand desk? And when does it make more sense to keep your old desk and place a sit-stand converter on top of it?
The biggest myth we have to dispel right away is that the decision should be cost-driven. Most consumers are surprised to learn there are excellent, highly-rated adjustable-height desks available for as little as $500 (e.g. Ellure), while there are only a few decent standing desk converters much cheaper than that. In fact, most highly-rated sit-stand converter models, with a few exceptions (e.g. ZipLift $299, Cadence Express $379, and Workfit-T $436) are in the $500-$1000 range, making them on par with full desk options. Price plays a role, no doubt, but solid options abound on either side, in the same price range.
First, the reasons for choosing a new desk:
1. You plan to use a walking treadmill–if not now, then potentially in the future. In this scenario it’s all about safety and stability, not to mention decor—no one wants something looking like a Rube Goldberg contraption in their office. If you’re going to build a standing/walking workstation—and in particular if you’re going to get all three modalities out of one desk (sitting, standing AND walking), you’re going to want a standing desk with sufficient height range (at least 50″–and the more the better), sufficient width, and a built-in SteadyType keyboard tray for the best ergonomics, stability, and style. There are few standing desk converters with the vertical reach and stability to work well as part of a walking workstation (e.g. ZipLift), but you’d absolutely want to securely clamp them to the desk for safety reasons. Best to stick with Omega desks such as the Everest, Olympus and Denali if you’re contemplating working while walking.
2. You need a lot of desk surface area. A very common complaint about standing desk converters is that they can take up the center of your desk but lack a sufficiently large working surface (free of monitors, keyboard, mouse, etc.) for all your papers. If you’re standing, you don’t want to reach down from afar to grab papers. So having an entire desk come up or down to your level is a big bonus. The caveat here is that “hover style” standing desk converters—such as the Cadence, Cadence Express, Helium Junior, Quickstand Lite, ESI Climb, and Ergotron Workfit-A—can be moved out of the way with a light push, giving you back access to virtually your entire desktop, at least when sitting. When standing, you’d still need to reach down to your papers.
3. You want the most stable experience. To be sure, there are also cheap standing desks on the market that wobble ridiculously as you type. Always check out our reviews first before getting razzled and dazzled by slick photos and marketing copy. But as a general rule, height-adjustable desks will give you an overall better experience in terms of monitor shake. If you’re building an ergonomic workstation that means you’re also adding a monitor arm, and any vibration in the desk will be transmitted to and amplified by the monitor arm, particularly if you use a heavy monitor or set of monitors. So stability is king, and you’ll definitely want to check out our comparative standing desk reviews to pick the most solid desk you can find in your budget range.
That said, most—though certainly not all—standing desk converters are going to be a bit shaky. Of course there’s a spectrum of stability in these units as well, but paying more doesn’t always guarantee a more stable platform. In fact the most stable of all, the ZipLift, is a relatively inexpensive $299 device, while the least stable, the Quickstand, costs twice as much. Pretty much everything under $299, and certainly the many cheap, gimmicky, Chinese-made products you’ll find for under $100 on Amazon, are going to make you feel like a leaf on a tree in a late October breeze. Check out our comprehensive standing desk converter reviews to learn more about each model’s pros and cons.
4. You want real ergonomics. Let’s be blunt. A standing desk converter will always be a compromise of some degree when it comes to ergonomics. Typical deficiencies for many of them are no tilting adjustment in the keyboard platform and no ability to mount an ergonomic keyboard tray, the inability to mount a good monitor arm, and general instability that causes your hands to tense up when trying to avoid making a typo. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, read our reviews first, to find out which ones are going to score highest on ergonomic adjustability (several of them are really good, to be sure). The point is, when you buy a standing desk you know that there’s at least going to be a solution, at least 95% of the time, for setting up good keyboard tray and monitor arm accessories to complete the workstation. The 5% to avoid? Those that have no way of mounting a keyboard tray, and those that are too thick to edge clamp a monitor arm to (e.g. the fancy Stir Kinetic Desk F-1 which fails on both points, for only $4,990). The 5% that’ll give you best ergonomics? Those with built-in SteadyType trays like the Omega Everest, Olympus and Denali, that can also accommodate virtually any monitor arm on the market.
Now, the reasons for a sit-stand converter:
1. You have a built-in desk. Unless you’re willing to do a little DIY work or get a contractor in to remove a section of your built-in counter, you have no other option. Note: many people who work in cubicles are unaware that their desktop surfaces can easily be pulled out, often without even breaking out a tool box. Upsilon desks and many of the UpTown and Olympus corner desk models, with their 24″ deep counter tops, are highly popular in cubicle scenarios such as these. Also note that if you’re going to try to position your standing desk converter into the corner of your cubicle, look for models with tapered back corners for the ideal fit. Take careful measurements to make sure your standing desk converter of choice will fit properly and work with your monitors, computer, and keyboard setup.
2. Your desk is a cherished heirloom and you don’t want to stop using it. Hey, we get it. Our only advice then is make sure to select a standing desk converter that won’t damage the finish on your desktop.
3. You don’t want to lose your file drawer space. If you need to frequently access your drawers when sitting or standing at your desk, we totally get that, too. However, be aware there is also the solution of using mobile file cabinets under your sit-to-stand desk, and the bonus is that these wheeled babies can double as a convenient stool for visitors to sit on.
Still struggling with which way to go? Ping our workplace wellness solutions specialists at live chat, or give them a call at 844-DON’T-SIT (844.366.8748). They’d be more than happy to help you put together the ideal workstation to fit your situation.