CompareComparing...

Fellowes Office Suites Underdesk Keyboard Drawer Reviews

Now Reading
Fellowes Office Suites Underdesk Keyboard Drawer Reviews

Overview
Review Summary

The Office Suites Underdesk Keyboard Drawer by Fellowes is one of the most popular keyboard drawers available, as well as one of the cheapest. It lacks tilt adjustment, which is a key feature of any ergonomic keyboard tray (as opposed to a keyboard drawer, which is inherently not an ergonomic device so much as a stowing mechanism). For typists on a budget, the Underdesk Keyboard Drawer is slightly better than no tray at all, but without a tilt adjustment your wrists may end up paying the price.

Street Price

$23.95

Shipping

Free 2 day shipping with Amazon Prime

Warranty

3 year limited warranty

Product Weight

3.9 lbs

Where to Buy
Positives

As cheap as it gets. Adjustable height levels, slides easily under your desk using conventional drawer slides as opposed to a “keyboard arm” mechanism. Includes a retractable mouse platform, albeit not height or angle adjustable; but, for those who don’t use a mouse it’s nice to be able to tuck the mouse platform under the keyboard and have it out of the way.

Negatives

Lack of ergonomic tilt makes it hard to recommend. Installation was surprisingly difficult. Screwdriver required to adjust height. Feels very flimsy and breakable. Additionally, it’s unable to install on most standing desks due to a 16” track colliding with the crossbars.

Experts' Rating
Expert Rating
Stability
Reliability
Quality and Aesthetics
Ergonomics
Value
Bottom Line

If you can’t afford a keyboard tray with tilt adjustment and other ergonomic accoutrements, then this Fellowes Keyboard Tray is a fine accessory for your workstation that lets you tuck your keyboard out of the way when you’re note using it. However, it ranges from difficult to impossible to install on standing desks due to a 16”-long track, and its old-fashioned, bare-bones design lacks a modern perspective on proper typing ergonomics. It’s a fine product, but if possible, you should save your wrists some strain and look for a higher quality tray that has actual ergonomic adjustment features.

Experts' Rating
You have rated this
Review Details

Our Take on the Fellowes Keyboard Tray

We included the Fellowes’ Office Suites Underdesk Keyboard Drawer in our round-up of ergonomic keyboard trays because it’s not uncommon for people to mistakenly refer to a “keyboard drawer” as a “keyboard tray,” when in fact they are really two different animals. A drawer’s function is to allow you to stow they keyboard away when not in use, while freeing up your desktop real estate for writing or drawing. A tray, in industry parlance, is an ergonomically-adjustable keyboard tray, or “AKT.”  

The Fellowes Keyboard Drawer is a product many people are already familiar with. It’s a popular choice for budget-conscious folks who work from home, or for companies that are especially frugal and not particularly concerned with ergonomic accommodations for its employees. This is a product that has succeeded in the marketplace by being the lowest on the price totem pole, a strategy that naturally elicits skepticism. The purpose of this review is to find out just how far your $25 will take you.

The Fellowes Keyboard Tray succeeds at its primary purpose:  it easily stows your keyboard out of the way when not in use. Is that functionality worth the $25 that this humble keyboard tray will cost you? The answer is yes, but only if you can’t afford anything better. Its features aren’t bad, it’s just that the tray is missing the ergonomic features of an AKT, most importantly the ability to change the tilt angle of the keyboard in order to remove flexion and extension from the user’s wrists.

We can’t wholeheartedly endorse any keyboard holder that does not support negative tilt for typing. This is an essential feature for reducing the strain on your wrists, and reducing the instances of RSIs (repetitive strain injuries) like carpal tunnel syndrome.It’s kind of like this—imagine that you’re in a room that’s on fire, and the whole building is collapsing. This drawer puts out the fire, but doesn’t do anything to prevent you from turning into a pancake. In all fairness, however, a true ergonomically-adjustable keyboard tray will set your wallet on fire, relatively speaking. If you ask us it’s wiser to invest upfront in a good ergonomic workstation setup than to do it after all the medical bills and physical therapy hours when RSIs have already manifested.

Day to Day Use

The drawer has a bit of a flimsy feel to it, as it’s made from hollow plastic, but that doesn’t hamper its functionality in any way. Plus, it’s backed up by a 3-year warranty, which is reasonably good for a product in this price range. Shaking is minimal but definitely present. You wouldn’t want to use it for treadmill desking, but for the old-fashioned sitting desk, this drawer does the trick.

Fellowes Keyboard Drawer

However, when standing at an adjustable-height desk, tilt angle becomes an even more important feature, and it’s practically vital for treadmill desking. Additionally, the tray is unlikely to even fit on your standing desk. It requires 16” of under-desk clearance, which is more than most standing desks have due to their horizontal crossbars. Higher end track-mounted keyboard trays usually support full 360° pivoting, so you can install the tracks sideways on standing desks to avoid the crossbars learn how. This tray requires the track to be perpendicular to the crossbars, and there’s simply not enough space underneath the tabletop on most sit-stand desks. For these reasons, we can’t really recommend this tray for anything but a traditional fixed-height desk—and as our name implies, we don’t recommend that kind of desk for any kind of prolonged daily use.

Also of note: in order to adjust the keyboard drawer’s height, you must unscrew it and reinstall it at a different position on its mounting brackets. So while this tray is technically “height-adjustable,” it is not an easy feat. If you manage to install it on a standing desk, you may find that one height works best for sitting and another for standing. Pricier trays let you adjust this kind of thing on the fly.

Finally, the mouse platform is lackluster, but that shouldn’t really come as a surprise. It’s there, and it will hold your mouse. It doesn’t swivel, so you’ll have to reach in order to get to it (an ergonomic no-no). Be advised: Some mice might not work well with its slick plastic surface and small surface area.  You’ll probably end up adorning it with a mousepad that’s too big.

Unboxing and Installation

Maybe we were foolish in assuming that a lower cost keyboard tray would bring with it a lower time investment for installation. This proved not to be the case, as you’re still required to use a mounting template to drill holes into the bottom of your desktop for mounting the drawer slides. Now, unlike other trays with mounting templates, the Fellowes Keyboard Tray does not “attach” to the desk in any way before it’s screwed in. So while you can use the template to drill pilot holes, you’ll still be required to hold the track up to the bottom of your desk while screwing it in, a task that’s exceedingly difficult without another person helping you. We found it easier to simply flip the desk over and screw in the track that way. The installation was pretty standard after that—we just really don’t like clearing our desks off to flip them over.

The Takeaway

The Office Suites Underdesk Keyboard Drawer is a fine choice for those on the tightest of budgets who aren’t seeking any of the available ergonomic features of a true adjustable keyboard tray. For a product that’s basically as cheap as it gets, it surprised us with a three year warranty and a functional, if minimal, design. The lack of tilt, however, is a fatal flaw that you may end up missing if you do decide to purchase it. If you’ve ever suffered from carpal tunnel, or if you want to make sure you never do, you should look elsewhere. If you’re just looking for a more comfortable typing experience on a keyboard that’s a few inches below your desk, the Fellowes Keyboard Tray will do just fine.

Want to check out more ergonomic keyboard trays? See our comparison review of the most popular models.

And sign up for our monthly newsletter to get the latest office fitness news!

Where to Buy
  • Tray size: 22” x 11.6”
  • Mouse platform size: 7.5” x 7.5”
  • Tilt: none
  • Height adjustment: 3”
  • Track length: 16”
  • Installs on standing desks: only if track fits
  • Installation: moderately difficult
  • Required for installation: drill, screwdriver, tape
  • Weight: 3.9 lbs

3 year limited warranty

Comments
Leave a response

Rate It, If You Have It!